Stranačko odmetanje narodnih poslanika u Srbiji 1990-2020.
Abstract
Problem stranačkog odmetanja izabranih predstavnika često može imati ozbiljne posledice po demokratske procese i s razlogom izaziva kontroverze. Međutim, do sada nije postojao sveobuhvatan pregled stranačkog odmetanja izabranih predsednika u Srbiji tokom tri decenije višestranačja. U ovom radu se odmetanje poslanika konceptualizuje i razdvaja od povezanih fenomena, koji se često svi nazivaju „preletanjem“. Korišćenjem primarnih izvora, medijskih navoda i literature, sakupljeni su podaci o poslanicima koji su ostali bez mandata, odmetnuli se od stranke ili prebegli u druge stranke. Odmetanje se analizira u institucionalnom kontekstu, naročito u svetlu pravila koja su određivala odnos poslanika i stranke. Dok su stranke mogle da kažnjavaju poslanike oduzimanjem mandata, odmetanja je bilo manje, ali kako se ovaj odnos menjao u smeru slobode poslanika da odlučuje o mandatu, odmetanje je postajalo učestalije. Uprkos uvreženim stavovima građana, odmetanje nije samo nepoželjna anomalija demok...ratskog procesa, već može da ima i važnu korektivnu ulogu. Zbog toga se na samom kraju rada diskutuje o tome kako da se praksa odmetanja u Srbiji bolje reguliše, i predlaže nekoliko načina: međustranački paktovi, institucionalno sankcionisanje prebega, ukidanje podsticaja za oportuno odmetanje i informisanje glasača.
Party switching of elected representatives can have serious consequences for
the democratic process, and it is considered controversial for justifiable reasons. However,
until now there was no comprehensive overview of legislative party switching in Serbia
during the three decades of multiparty elections. In this article, I conceptualized legislative
party switching, and differentiated it from other related phenomena, which are all usually
bundled together, and described as defections. Relying on primary sources, media, and
literature on historical elections and parliament sessions, I collected the data on representatives that lost their seats, abandoned their parties, or switched to other parties during their
terms of office. Party switching is then analyzed in the institutional context, in particular,
as depending on the rules that determined the relations between representatives and their
parties. As long as the parties were able to sanction the representatives by retrievin...g their
mandates, there was less legislative party switching. When this changed, and the control
of the mandate moved from the parties to the elected representatives, party switching
increased. Even though citizens mostly have negative views of party switching, it should not
be understood only as an unwanted anomaly of the democratic process, instead, it could
have a corrective role in democracies. Therefore, the article concludes with a discussion
on different ways legislative party switching could be better regulated in the future: through agreements between the parties, institutional mechanisms for sanctioning of party
defectors, reducing incentives for opportunistic behavior, and better informed voters.
Keywords:
poslanici / mandat / stranačko odmetanje / skupština / izboriSource:
Kako, koga i zašto smo birali: izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020. godine, 2020, 959-989Publisher:
- Beograd: Institut za političke studije, Službeni glasnik
Note:
- Zbornik radova sa naučne konferencije 'Izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020', u organizaciji Fakulteta političkih nauka Univerziteta u Beogradu i Instituta za političke studije, održane 9. i 10. decembra 2020. godine u Beogradu.
Collections
Institution/Community
IFDTTY - CHAP AU - Ilić, Vujo PY - 2020 UR - http://rifdt.instifdt.bg.ac.rs/123456789/2236 AB - Problem stranačkog odmetanja izabranih predstavnika često može imati ozbiljne posledice po demokratske procese i s razlogom izaziva kontroverze. Međutim, do sada nije postojao sveobuhvatan pregled stranačkog odmetanja izabranih predsednika u Srbiji tokom tri decenije višestranačja. U ovom radu se odmetanje poslanika konceptualizuje i razdvaja od povezanih fenomena, koji se često svi nazivaju „preletanjem“. Korišćenjem primarnih izvora, medijskih navoda i literature, sakupljeni su podaci o poslanicima koji su ostali bez mandata, odmetnuli se od stranke ili prebegli u druge stranke. Odmetanje se analizira u institucionalnom kontekstu, naročito u svetlu pravila koja su određivala odnos poslanika i stranke. Dok su stranke mogle da kažnjavaju poslanike oduzimanjem mandata, odmetanja je bilo manje, ali kako se ovaj odnos menjao u smeru slobode poslanika da odlučuje o mandatu, odmetanje je postajalo učestalije. Uprkos uvreženim stavovima građana, odmetanje nije samo nepoželjna anomalija demokratskog procesa, već može da ima i važnu korektivnu ulogu. Zbog toga se na samom kraju rada diskutuje o tome kako da se praksa odmetanja u Srbiji bolje reguliše, i predlaže nekoliko načina: međustranački paktovi, institucionalno sankcionisanje prebega, ukidanje podsticaja za oportuno odmetanje i informisanje glasača. AB - Party switching of elected representatives can have serious consequences for the democratic process, and it is considered controversial for justifiable reasons. However, until now there was no comprehensive overview of legislative party switching in Serbia during the three decades of multiparty elections. In this article, I conceptualized legislative party switching, and differentiated it from other related phenomena, which are all usually bundled together, and described as defections. Relying on primary sources, media, and literature on historical elections and parliament sessions, I collected the data on representatives that lost their seats, abandoned their parties, or switched to other parties during their terms of office. Party switching is then analyzed in the institutional context, in particular, as depending on the rules that determined the relations between representatives and their parties. As long as the parties were able to sanction the representatives by retrieving their mandates, there was less legislative party switching. When this changed, and the control of the mandate moved from the parties to the elected representatives, party switching increased. Even though citizens mostly have negative views of party switching, it should not be understood only as an unwanted anomaly of the democratic process, instead, it could have a corrective role in democracies. Therefore, the article concludes with a discussion on different ways legislative party switching could be better regulated in the future: through agreements between the parties, institutional mechanisms for sanctioning of party defectors, reducing incentives for opportunistic behavior, and better informed voters. PB - Beograd: Institut za političke studije, Službeni glasnik T2 - Kako, koga i zašto smo birali: izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020. godine T2 - Legislative party switching in Serbia 1990–2020 T1 - Stranačko odmetanje narodnih poslanika u Srbiji 1990-2020. SP - 959 EP - 989 UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rifdt_2236 ER -
@inbook{ author = "Ilić, Vujo", year = "2020", abstract = "Problem stranačkog odmetanja izabranih predstavnika često može imati ozbiljne posledice po demokratske procese i s razlogom izaziva kontroverze. Međutim, do sada nije postojao sveobuhvatan pregled stranačkog odmetanja izabranih predsednika u Srbiji tokom tri decenije višestranačja. U ovom radu se odmetanje poslanika konceptualizuje i razdvaja od povezanih fenomena, koji se često svi nazivaju „preletanjem“. Korišćenjem primarnih izvora, medijskih navoda i literature, sakupljeni su podaci o poslanicima koji su ostali bez mandata, odmetnuli se od stranke ili prebegli u druge stranke. Odmetanje se analizira u institucionalnom kontekstu, naročito u svetlu pravila koja su određivala odnos poslanika i stranke. Dok su stranke mogle da kažnjavaju poslanike oduzimanjem mandata, odmetanja je bilo manje, ali kako se ovaj odnos menjao u smeru slobode poslanika da odlučuje o mandatu, odmetanje je postajalo učestalije. Uprkos uvreženim stavovima građana, odmetanje nije samo nepoželjna anomalija demokratskog procesa, već može da ima i važnu korektivnu ulogu. Zbog toga se na samom kraju rada diskutuje o tome kako da se praksa odmetanja u Srbiji bolje reguliše, i predlaže nekoliko načina: međustranački paktovi, institucionalno sankcionisanje prebega, ukidanje podsticaja za oportuno odmetanje i informisanje glasača., Party switching of elected representatives can have serious consequences for the democratic process, and it is considered controversial for justifiable reasons. However, until now there was no comprehensive overview of legislative party switching in Serbia during the three decades of multiparty elections. In this article, I conceptualized legislative party switching, and differentiated it from other related phenomena, which are all usually bundled together, and described as defections. Relying on primary sources, media, and literature on historical elections and parliament sessions, I collected the data on representatives that lost their seats, abandoned their parties, or switched to other parties during their terms of office. Party switching is then analyzed in the institutional context, in particular, as depending on the rules that determined the relations between representatives and their parties. As long as the parties were able to sanction the representatives by retrieving their mandates, there was less legislative party switching. When this changed, and the control of the mandate moved from the parties to the elected representatives, party switching increased. Even though citizens mostly have negative views of party switching, it should not be understood only as an unwanted anomaly of the democratic process, instead, it could have a corrective role in democracies. Therefore, the article concludes with a discussion on different ways legislative party switching could be better regulated in the future: through agreements between the parties, institutional mechanisms for sanctioning of party defectors, reducing incentives for opportunistic behavior, and better informed voters.", publisher = "Beograd: Institut za političke studije, Službeni glasnik", journal = "Kako, koga i zašto smo birali: izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020. godine, Legislative party switching in Serbia 1990–2020", booktitle = "Stranačko odmetanje narodnih poslanika u Srbiji 1990-2020.", pages = "959-989", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rifdt_2236" }
Ilić, V.. (2020). Stranačko odmetanje narodnih poslanika u Srbiji 1990-2020.. in Kako, koga i zašto smo birali: izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020. godine Beograd: Institut za političke studije, Službeni glasnik., 959-989. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rifdt_2236
Ilić V. Stranačko odmetanje narodnih poslanika u Srbiji 1990-2020.. in Kako, koga i zašto smo birali: izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020. godine. 2020;:959-989. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rifdt_2236 .
Ilić, Vujo, "Stranačko odmetanje narodnih poslanika u Srbiji 1990-2020." in Kako, koga i zašto smo birali: izbori u Srbiji 1990-2020. godine (2020):959-989, https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rifdt_2236 .