TY  - JOUR
AU  - Karpenko, Ivan A.
PY  - 2023
UR  - http://rifdt.instifdt.bg.ac.rs/123456789/3036
AB  - The article considers new approaches to four of Zeno’s paradoxes: the Arrow, Achilles and the Tortoise, the Dichotomy, and the Stadium. The paradoxes are analyzed in the light of current research in the field of elementary particle physics and some promising directions in the development of the quantum gravity. Physical theories, provided with the necessary philosophical interpretation, are used in order to clarify Zeno’s paradoxes and to search for answers to them. The text shows that using modern approaches to solve the paradoxes is not effective, because the paradoxes become irrelevant when analyzed in the context of microworld physics, at very small scales.

The main part of the paper is devoted to demonstrating this circum- stance – that the questions posed by the paradoxes are impossible to answer (at least in their classical interpretation). As a possible explanation, the article puts forward that in the formulation of the paradoxes, the properties of the macroworld and the microworld are mixed (which is historically justified, given the intuitive homogeneity of the large and the small, and the fact that non-classical physics – quantum mechanics – did not emerge until the twentieth century); that is, from the observation of large physical objects, a transition is made to the infinitely small in terms of discreteness and continuity. However, the principles of organization of space at very small scales are beginning to be clarified in general terms only now, and, perhaps, these principles may turn out to be quite far from the classical ideas about fundamental physical reality.
AB  - U članku se razmatraju novi pristupi pitanju četiri Zenonova paradoksa: strela, Ahil i kornjača, Dihotomija i Stadion. Paradoksi su analizirani u svetlu aktuelnih istraživanja u oblasti fizike elementarnih čestica i nekih obećavajućih pravaca u razvoju kvantne gravitacije. Fizičke
teorije, opremljene neophodnim filozofskim tumačenjem, koriste se kako bi se razjasnili Zenonovi paradoksi i tražili odgovori na njih. Tekst pokazuje da korišćenje savremenih pristupa
za rešavanje paradoksa nije efikasno, jer paradoksi postaju irelevantni kada se analiziraju u
kontekstu fizike mikrosveta, na veoma malim razmerama.
Glavni deo rada posvećen je demonstraciji ove okolnosti – da je na pitanja koja postavljaju paradoksi nemoguće odgovoriti (barem u njihovoj klasičnoj interpretaciji). Kao moguće
objašnjenje, u članku se navodi da se u formulisanju paradoksa mešaju svojstva makrosveta
i mikrosveta (što je istorijski opravdano, s obzirom na intuitivnu homogenost velikog i malog
i činjenicu da neklasična fizika – kvantna mehanika – pojavila se tek u dvadesetom veku);
odnosno od posmatranja velikih fizičkih objekata prelazi se na beskonačno male u smislu
diskretnosti i kontinuiteta. Međutim, principi organizacije prostora u veoma malim razmerama počinju da se uopšteno razjašnjavaju tek sada i, možda, ovi principi se mogu ispostaviti
kao prilično strani klasičnim idejama o fundamentalnoj fizičkoj stvarnosti.
PB  - Beograd : Institut za filozofiju i društvenu teoriju
T2  - Filozofija i društvo / Philosophy and Society
T1  - Zeno’s Paradoxes and the Quantum Microworld: What the Aporias Convey
T1  - Zenonovi paradoksi i kvantni mikrosvet: šta govore aporije
IS  - 3
VL  - 34
SP  - 438
EP  - 451
DO  - 10.2298/FID2303438K
ER  - 

@article{
author = "Karpenko, Ivan A.",
year = "2023",
abstract = "The article considers new approaches to four of Zeno’s paradoxes: the Arrow, Achilles and the Tortoise, the Dichotomy, and the Stadium. The paradoxes are analyzed in the light of current research in the field of elementary particle physics and some promising directions in the development of the quantum gravity. Physical theories, provided with the necessary philosophical interpretation, are used in order to clarify Zeno’s paradoxes and to search for answers to them. The text shows that using modern approaches to solve the paradoxes is not effective, because the paradoxes become irrelevant when analyzed in the context of microworld physics, at very small scales.

The main part of the paper is devoted to demonstrating this circum- stance – that the questions posed by the paradoxes are impossible to answer (at least in their classical interpretation). As a possible explanation, the article puts forward that in the formulation of the paradoxes, the properties of the macroworld and the microworld are mixed (which is historically justified, given the intuitive homogeneity of the large and the small, and the fact that non-classical physics – quantum mechanics – did not emerge until the twentieth century); that is, from the observation of large physical objects, a transition is made to the infinitely small in terms of discreteness and continuity. However, the principles of organization of space at very small scales are beginning to be clarified in general terms only now, and, perhaps, these principles may turn out to be quite far from the classical ideas about fundamental physical reality., U članku se razmatraju novi pristupi pitanju četiri Zenonova paradoksa: strela, Ahil i kornjača, Dihotomija i Stadion. Paradoksi su analizirani u svetlu aktuelnih istraživanja u oblasti fizike elementarnih čestica i nekih obećavajućih pravaca u razvoju kvantne gravitacije. Fizičke
teorije, opremljene neophodnim filozofskim tumačenjem, koriste se kako bi se razjasnili Zenonovi paradoksi i tražili odgovori na njih. Tekst pokazuje da korišćenje savremenih pristupa
za rešavanje paradoksa nije efikasno, jer paradoksi postaju irelevantni kada se analiziraju u
kontekstu fizike mikrosveta, na veoma malim razmerama.
Glavni deo rada posvećen je demonstraciji ove okolnosti – da je na pitanja koja postavljaju paradoksi nemoguće odgovoriti (barem u njihovoj klasičnoj interpretaciji). Kao moguće
objašnjenje, u članku se navodi da se u formulisanju paradoksa mešaju svojstva makrosveta
i mikrosveta (što je istorijski opravdano, s obzirom na intuitivnu homogenost velikog i malog
i činjenicu da neklasična fizika – kvantna mehanika – pojavila se tek u dvadesetom veku);
odnosno od posmatranja velikih fizičkih objekata prelazi se na beskonačno male u smislu
diskretnosti i kontinuiteta. Međutim, principi organizacije prostora u veoma malim razmerama počinju da se uopšteno razjašnjavaju tek sada i, možda, ovi principi se mogu ispostaviti
kao prilično strani klasičnim idejama o fundamentalnoj fizičkoj stvarnosti.",
publisher = "Beograd : Institut za filozofiju i društvenu teoriju",
journal = "Filozofija i društvo / Philosophy and Society",
title = "Zeno’s Paradoxes and the Quantum Microworld: What the Aporias Convey, Zenonovi paradoksi i kvantni mikrosvet: šta govore aporije",
number = "3",
volume = "34",
pages = "438-451",
doi = "10.2298/FID2303438K"
}

Karpenko, I. A.. (2023). Zeno’s Paradoxes and the Quantum Microworld: What the Aporias Convey. in Filozofija i društvo / Philosophy and Society
Beograd : Institut za filozofiju i društvenu teoriju., 34(3), 438-451.
https://doi.org/10.2298/FID2303438K

Karpenko IA. Zeno’s Paradoxes and the Quantum Microworld: What the Aporias Convey. in Filozofija i društvo / Philosophy and Society. 2023;34(3):438-451.
doi:10.2298/FID2303438K .

Karpenko, Ivan A., "Zeno’s Paradoxes and the Quantum Microworld: What the Aporias Convey" in Filozofija i društvo / Philosophy and Society, 34, no. 3 (2023):438-451,
https://doi.org/10.2298/FID2303438K . .