TY  - JOUR
AU  - János Tóth, Szilárd
PY  - 2019
UR  - http://journal.instifdt.bg.ac.rs/index.php?journal=fid&page=article&op=view&path%5B%5D=749
UR  - http://rifdt.instifdt.bg.ac.rs/123456789/1984
AB  - My paper is on the republican version of patriotism and its justification, as developed most systematically by Philip Pettit and Maurizio Viroli. The essence of the justification is as follows: patriotism is to be viewed as valuable insofar as it is an indispensable instrument for the upholding of the central republican ideal, namely freedom understood as non-domination. My primary aim is to evaluate the normative force of this justification. In the first section, I introduce minimal descriptive definitions of the concepts of patriotism and the patria. Second, I reconstruct the republican patria-ideal to which patriotism is linked to. In the third section, I reconstruct the republican justification of patriotism. Finally, I ask what we justify when we justify republican patriotism. Two views are prevalent in this regard. According to the first, republican patriotic motivation, similarly to its justification, ought to be instrumental itself too (Pettit, Viroli). I argue that this view is untenable, since it is in tension with the minimal definition of patriotism. The conclusion is that the other view – according to which the patriotic motivation ought to be of intrinsic character (Miller) – possesses greater normative force.
AB  - Članak se bavi republikanskom verzijom patriotizma i njenim opravdanjem, sa posebnim osvrtom na sistematizovane teorije Filipa Petita i Mauricija Virolija. Srž opravdanja je slede-će: patriotizam je vredan utoliko što je neophodan instrument za podržavanje centralnog ideala republikanizma, naime, slobode kao ne-dominacije. Moja glavna namera je da preis-pitam normativnu snagu ove argumentacije. U prvom delu članka uvodim minimalne deskrip-tivne definicije patriotizma i domovine. U drugom delu rekonstruišem republikanski ideal domovine, zatim u trećem rekonstruišem republikansko opravdanje patriotizma. U posled-njem delu preispitujem šta tačno opravdamo prilikom opravdanja republikanskog patriotiz-ma. Dve perspektive su preovlađajuće u tom pogledu. Prema prvoj, republikanska patriotska motivacija mora da bude, kao i njeno opravdanje, instrumentalnog karaktera (Petit, Viroli). Smatram da je ova argumentacija nebranjiva jer je u izvesnoj napetosti sa minimalnom defi-nicijom patriotizma. Prema tome, zaključujem da druga pojmovna strategija, prema kojoj pa-triotska motivacija mora da bude intrinsična (Miler), ima veću normativnu snagu.
PB  - Beograd : Institut za filozofiju i društvenu teoriju
T2  - Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society
T1  - Justifying Republican Patriotism
IS  - 2
VL  - 30
SP  - 287
EP  - 303
DO  - 10.2298/FID1902287T
ER  - 

@article{
author = "János Tóth, Szilárd",
year = "2019",
abstract = "My paper is on the republican version of patriotism and its justification, as developed most systematically by Philip Pettit and Maurizio Viroli. The essence of the justification is as follows: patriotism is to be viewed as valuable insofar as it is an indispensable instrument for the upholding of the central republican ideal, namely freedom understood as non-domination. My primary aim is to evaluate the normative force of this justification. In the first section, I introduce minimal descriptive definitions of the concepts of patriotism and the patria. Second, I reconstruct the republican patria-ideal to which patriotism is linked to. In the third section, I reconstruct the republican justification of patriotism. Finally, I ask what we justify when we justify republican patriotism. Two views are prevalent in this regard. According to the first, republican patriotic motivation, similarly to its justification, ought to be instrumental itself too (Pettit, Viroli). I argue that this view is untenable, since it is in tension with the minimal definition of patriotism. The conclusion is that the other view – according to which the patriotic motivation ought to be of intrinsic character (Miller) – possesses greater normative force., Članak se bavi republikanskom verzijom patriotizma i njenim opravdanjem, sa posebnim osvrtom na sistematizovane teorije Filipa Petita i Mauricija Virolija. Srž opravdanja je slede-će: patriotizam je vredan utoliko što je neophodan instrument za podržavanje centralnog ideala republikanizma, naime, slobode kao ne-dominacije. Moja glavna namera je da preis-pitam normativnu snagu ove argumentacije. U prvom delu članka uvodim minimalne deskrip-tivne definicije patriotizma i domovine. U drugom delu rekonstruišem republikanski ideal domovine, zatim u trećem rekonstruišem republikansko opravdanje patriotizma. U posled-njem delu preispitujem šta tačno opravdamo prilikom opravdanja republikanskog patriotiz-ma. Dve perspektive su preovlađajuće u tom pogledu. Prema prvoj, republikanska patriotska motivacija mora da bude, kao i njeno opravdanje, instrumentalnog karaktera (Petit, Viroli). Smatram da je ova argumentacija nebranjiva jer je u izvesnoj napetosti sa minimalnom defi-nicijom patriotizma. Prema tome, zaključujem da druga pojmovna strategija, prema kojoj pa-triotska motivacija mora da bude intrinsična (Miler), ima veću normativnu snagu.",
publisher = "Beograd : Institut za filozofiju i društvenu teoriju",
journal = "Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society",
title = "Justifying Republican Patriotism",
number = "2",
volume = "30",
pages = "287-303",
doi = "10.2298/FID1902287T"
}

János Tóth, S.. (2019). Justifying Republican Patriotism. in Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society
Beograd : Institut za filozofiju i društvenu teoriju., 30(2), 287-303.
https://doi.org/10.2298/FID1902287T

János Tóth S. Justifying Republican Patriotism. in Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society. 2019;30(2):287-303.
doi:10.2298/FID1902287T .

János Tóth, Szilárd, "Justifying Republican Patriotism" in Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society, 30, no. 2 (2019):287-303,
https://doi.org/10.2298/FID1902287T . .